Tuesday, 25 August 2015

Kubo in Cabanilla's Survey of Achaeological Sites in Tawi-Tawi

A SURVEY OF REPORTED ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES IN TAWI-TAWI 
By Israel B. Cabanilla 

Kubo is located in Tawi-Tawi Island. The distance between Bongao and Kubo is fifty (50) kilometers west as the crow flies. We could not go directly to the site and had to take a circuitous route because of seaweed farms and coral reefs that abound in the general area. There were two sites explored in Kubo: one, the archaeological site, below the sea level and the shrine of Sheik Makdum, ten (10) meters above sea level. 

Dungon has a reputation for being a no man’s land. If Tawi-Tawi and Sulu have a reputation of being dangerous, Dungon, by consensus among the residents of Tawi-Tawi, is a place to avoid. All this is folklore. One of the primary reasons given by the residents of Tawi-Tawi that perpetuates the myth of Dungon’s “notoriety” are the presence of armed illegal loggers and illegal fishermen, smugglers, pirates and other lawless elements. 

We went and stayed for a couple of days there, unarmed. And nothing untoward happened to us. The only danger that confronted us were natural: crocodiles (in the sea) and Malaria-carrying mosquitoes and the isolation from any commercial area. 

The archaeological site in Kubo alone is enough reason for going back to TawiTawi to conduct a full-scale archaeological campaign. This is very rich and humanly undisturbed. Within every radius of a hundred meters, artifacts, mostly of Chinese origin dating from 17th to 18th century abound. The site is surrounded by pristine mangroves on one side and by a dipterocarp forest on the other side. 

The sea in the area abound with marine and wildlife. I saw a crocodile and huge pawikan (sea turtle). There are monkeys and parrots too. Mosquitoes abound by the millions—one of the reasons why this place is sparsely populated. There is also no mosque in this predominantly Muslim area. The Ilocanos who were sent there during the early 1950’s have all left, mostly due to malaria. 

The site is rich but it is located in an area that is adversely affected by the tide. During the high tide the artifacts are covered with water but when the tide ebbs the artifacts can be seen. This is one of the problems that will confront the excavator. The inaccessibility of the place is another reason why it would be expensive to excavate in this site. 

Dungon is half a day’s boat ride from Bongao. If an archaeological excavation is to be conducted all of these problems must be factored in. But the rewards of a scientific excavation will be amply returned in terms of artifacts recovered and information gathered. From surface finds alone, we were able to see all sorts of trade ware sherds—plates, bowls, jars, earthenware sherds and it is probable that we will be able to get a lot of whole pieces if there would be an excavation. 

The logistics of mounting that campaign is going to be expensive and quite tedious and slow because excavation can only be done when the tide is low. The excavation will be limited and dictated by the ebb and flow of the tides. One will always be submerged in water and underlying soft soil. The dangers of being infected by Malaria is real. This is one of the reasons why this site is safe for now—relative isolation from the rest of the world. 

The value of the site archaeologically is that it is undisturbed and therefore a very good site for understanding the 17th and 18th century Tawi-Tawi. Other sites, such as on the other islands I have visited, will be better understood if it is compared with the excavations in Dungon.

A Dungon archaeological site may be made the basis for comparing other islands which have been disturbed that have deposits of 17th and 18th century artifacts. I do not know if we would be able to find any midden sites in the July 2000 60 Hukay vol. 2 no. 2 area but certainly it would just be a matter of time and more exploration to pinpoint the burials and the middens. Dungon, therefore, is the primary archaeological target for the understanding of the 17th and 18th century Tawi-Tawi. Beyer (1947) was correct in his assessment of the area. 

Source: http://journals.upd.edu.ph/index.php/asp/article/viewFile/4256/3864

Monday, 24 August 2015

Sultan Muwallil Wasit I parents, children and grandchildren

Sultan Muwallil Wasit I (Pengiran Raja Bongsu Adipati) was the son of Sultan Muhammad Hassan of Brunei (1582-1598) from his "Putri Sulu" wife who is turn was the daughter of Sultan Muhammad al-Halim Buddiman (Pangiran Buddiman).[1]

It is claimed that Sultan Nasirud-Din II (1645-1648) and Sultan Salahud-Din Bakhtiar or Pangiran Baktial (1649/50-1680) were Sultan Muwallil Wasit I sons. [ref]

Of the Sultan Muwallil Wasit I's daughters, one was married to Sultan Qudarat of Maguindanao and another to Datu Balatamay (Baratamay), Rajah of Buayan. [ref]

Among Sultan Muwallil Wasit I grandchildren, Sultan Nurul-Azam (Pangyan Ampay, Sitti Kabila) daughter of Sultan Nasirud-Din II appear to have inherited from his father and reign for half a decade. She appears to be the only female ruler in the Sulu Sultanate [ref]

From his son, Pangiran Bakhtiar, three (3) grandsons succeeded the throne as Sultan Shahabud-Din (1685-1710), Sultan Mustafa Shafi ud-Din (1710-1718) and Sultan Badarud-Din I (1718-1732). [ref]

References:
[1] http://www.royalark.net/Brunei/brunei5.htm

Datu Aceh, Admiral of the Fleet

When Raja Bongsu came to Sulu to become Sultan Muwallil Wasit I, with him was Datu Aceh, an experienced fighter or warrior, as admiral of his fleet [1], as adviser [2] and as his aide-de-camp [3].

In 1627, "Datu Acheh, on official business in May Nilad for the Sultanate, was intercepted by Manila Spaniards on his way home; In retaliation, Sultan Wasit led 2,000 Tausug warriors in raiding Spanish shipyards in Camarines south of May Nilad"[3].

In 1629, "the Sultanate of Sulu sent anew another expedition under Datu Acheh to attack Spanish settlements in Camarines, Samar, Leyte and Bohol." [3]

In 1646, a treaty was signed with the Spaniards. This was unacceptable to Datu Aceh, so he returned to Brunei, [2] six years after the court was move to Dungon with the Capture of Jolo in 1638.



References:
[1] Reyes, Portia L.. "Bungsu, Raja (of Sulu)." Encyclopaedia of Islam, THREE. Edited by: Kate Fleet, Gudrun Krämer, Denis Matringe, John Nawas, Everett Rowson. Brill Online, 2015. Reference. 24 August 2015 <http://brillonline.nl/entries/encyclopaedia-of-islam-3/bungsu-raja-of-sulu-COM_23370> ;First appeared online: 2009; First Print Edition: issn: 1573-3912, 2009-04

[2] Saunders, Graham. (2013). A History of Brunei. Routledge. p. 63 - https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=DUv8AQAAQBAJ&pg=PA63&lpg=PA63&dq=datu+aceh,+raja+bongsu&source=bl&ots=Y3qbl6g_H5&sig=F5YQ9fzLQ33OF_8MbhPf_dsrCTA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CBwQ6AEwAGoVChMIzPzFubbDxwIVRSSOCh3zBwHw#v=onepage&q=datu%20aceh%2C%20raja%20bongsu&f=false

[3] Ang, Josiah C. Historical Timeline of the Royal Sultanate of SuluIncluding Related Events of Neighboring Peoples. -http://www.seasite.niu.edu/tagalog/Modules/Modules/MuslimMindanao/historical_timeline_of_the_royal.htm

Brunei's Pengiran Muda Tengah in Tawi-Tawi?

Sultan Hashim Jalilul Alam Aqamaddin,
Brunei's 25th Sultan and father of Pengiran Muda Tengah
Today, Tawi-Tawi has a reputation as a place for 'rest and recreation' for those seeking solace from fast-paced urban life or the conflict-ridden province to its north. It seems this is not just true today but has also a historical precedence.

I have encountered texts with Brunei royalty calling Tawi-Tawi their "home away from home". Take the story of Pengiran Mudah Tengah.

In 1889, Brunei's 25th ruler, Pengiran Temenggong Anak Hashim (regnal name Sultan Hashim Jalilul Alam Aqam al-Din and son of Sultan Omar Ali Saifuddin II) appointed his eldest son Pengiran Muda Besar Omar Ali Saifuddin as the acting Sultan to give him the experience needed when he took over the throne.

When the appointment was carried out, Sultan Hashim's second son (Pengiran Muda Tengah) left Brunei and stayed in Sabah before moving on to Tawi-Tawi. Pengiran Muda Tengah did return to Brunei in 1903 or 1904 to assume the throne when his elder brother died of smallbox. Unfortunately, his reign was cut short because he himself succumb to the same disease in 1905 after a ruling for 2 years. He died at Istana Kampung Ayer, Brunei town, His younger brother, Pengiran Muda Bongsu ascended the throne.

What is very interesting to note here is the time spent by Pengiran Muda Tengah in Sabah and Tawi-Tawi between 1889 and 1903 is roughly 14 years. 14 years?! Maybe he spent a third of his time in Tawi-Tawi? While in Tawi-Tawi, where did he resided? Did he married a local lady? Was he merely a 'tourist', a royal visitor or did he actually participate in local polity? Did he left royal descendants in Tawi-Tawi? Who were these royal descendants now?

Sources:

Sultan Muwallil Wasit I

Sultan Muwallil Wasit I is reported to be the first Sulu Sultan to establish court at Dungon, Tawi-Tawi [1]. Who was he?

Before he became Sultan, he was known as Raja Bongsu to the Spaniards [ref]

Genealogy
Was  he a son of Sultan Hassan of Brunei? Was his mother the sister of Sultan Batara Shah Tengah, his predecessor?

In the Brunei Sarsila (Genealogy) on Royal Ark website, He is known as "Y.A.M. Raja Bongsu, Pangiran Adipati Agung" and "who succeeded as H.H. Paduka Maulana Maha Sri Sultan Muwali al-Wasit Shah, Sultan of Sulu (s/o Putri Sulu). Therefore his father was Sultan Muhammad Hassan, Sultan of Brunei from 1582 to 1598, who married a daughter of Sultan Muhammad al-Halim Buddiman, Sultan of Sulu and sister of Sultan Batara Shah Tengah [2]

Interestingly, his maternal grandfather Sultan Muhammad al-Halim married and therefore his maternal grandmother was a "Putri Brunei" daughter of Brunei Sultan 'Abdu'l Kahar Jalil ul-Alam [3].

Marriage
Sultan Muwallil Wasit I is reported to have married a Sulu Princess (Putri Sulu), perhaps a distant cousin. He was not alone, his younger brother Pangiran Shahbandar Maharaja Laila also married another Putri Sulu. [9]

Royal Ascend
Sultan Muwallil Wasit I became the 9th Sulu Sultan succeeding his uncle Sultan Batara Shah Tengah. [ref] He reigned for about forty (40) years between 1610 and 1650 [4]. 

In his 3rd decade in power and with the Capture of Jolo by the Spaniards in 1638, he moved his royal court to Dungon [ref]. Thus he was in power and governing the state from Dungon for 12 years until his death! [ref]

Brothers in Power
He became Sulu Sultan 12 years after his eldest brother became Raja Tua 'Abdu'l Jalil [5] become Brunei Sultan Abdu'l Jalil ul-Akbar in 1598 and reigned up to 1659 [6].

Another older brother Raja Tengah Ibrahim disputed Raja Tua 'Abdu'l Jalil's claim to the throne, was expelled from Brunei and "eventually establishing his rule over parts of Sarawak, under the title of Sultan Anum Ibrahim 'Ali 'Umar Shah". [7]

Another older brother Raja Muhammad 'Ali eventually become Brunei Sultan Haji Muhammad 'Ali (1660 - 1661) ten years after the demise of Sultan Muwallil Wasit [8].

References:
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sultans_of_Sulu
[2] http://www.royalark.net/Brunei/brunei5.htm
[3] Ibid
[4] Same as [1]
[5] Same as [2]
[6] Ibid
[7] Ibid
[8] Ibid
[9] Ibid

How Dungon got its name?

A sample of a maturing Dungon Tree. (Copyright RAFI)
One possible origin of the name Dungon maybe the abundance of Dungon tree, Scientific Name: Heritiera sylvatica[1],  in the region as this type of tree can be found in forests at low and medium altitudes.

In the construction and outfitting of the boats for the Balangay Expedition in 2009, it was reported that the team sourced this type of trees from the Eastern region of Tawi-Tawi [2], the area where Dungon the historical place is situated.

References:
[1] http://rafi.org.ph/greenin-philippines/green-almanac/dungon/

Kubo in Cabanilla's Survey of Achaeological Sites in Tawi-Tawi

A SURVEY OF REPORTED ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES IN TAWI-TAWI  By Israel B. Cabanilla  Kubo is located in Tawi-Tawi Island. The distance be...